Philosopher (era)
Position
Statement
Connection
Ptahhotep (Egypt, Fifth Dynasty, c. 2400 BC.)
Agreement
Ma'at, the just order, calls for moderating covetousness and gluttony.
The ego that governs appetite must be measured.
Source : Maximes de Ptahhotep
Rishi (Inde, c. 1500-1200 AD.)
Agreement
One breathed without breath, by himself; desire is the first seed of the mind; two birds on a tree, one eats the fruit, the other watches.
Primary and creative energy; the consuming ego versus the witness, the soul.
Source : Rig-Véda, X, 129 ; I, 164, 20
Uddalaka Aruni (India, 9th-8th centuries BC.)
Agreement
Food is divided into three parts: the gross becomes excrement, the middle part becomes flesh, and the subtle part becomes mind.
The journey of food shapes the mind, and therefore the ego.
Source : Chāndogya Upaniṣad, VI, 5
Thalès de Milet (624-546 by J.-C.)
Agreement
The soul moves (the magnet has a soul); everything is full of gods.
The soul as a driving force diffused throughout all living things, including the hummingbird.
Source : Aristote, De l'âme (témoignage), I, 2, 405a19 ; I, 5, 411a7
Anaximandre de Milet (c. 610-c. 546 AD.)
Mixed
Unlimited principle (apeiron) from which everything is born and to which everything returns.
An undifferentiated source close to primal energy, but impersonal.
Source : Fragment (Simplicius), DK 12 B1
Lao-Tseu (VIe p. of. J.-C., tradition)
Agreement
Gathering the breath (qi) until it is as supple as a child's; the wise person effaces themselves and is fulfilled.
Purification of the ego through erasure; energy of the creative breath.
Source : Dao De Jing, ch. 10 ; ch. 7
Bouddha (~Ve p. of. J.-C.)
Mixed
No permanent self in the body, sensation, or consciousness; liberation comes from ceasing to identify.
Liberation of the ego; but not of a soul-receptacle.
Source : Anattalakkhaṇa Sutta (Saṃyutta Nikāya), SN 22.59
Confucius (551-479 by J.-C.)
Mixed
The Master forbade himself arbitrary opinion, obstinacy, rigidity and ego; to conquer himself in order to return to humanity.
Mastery of the ego; but within an ethical and ritual framework that the text excludes.
Source : Entretiens (Lunyu), IX, 4 ; XII, 1
Agreement
The limits of the soul are unfindable, so profound is its logos; the dry soul is the wisest; fire is the principle of life; I have sought myself.
A bottomless soul; a fire-light close to Tejas; a quest for self.
Source : Fragments, DK 22 B45 ; B118 ; B30 ; B101
Anaxagore de Clazomènes (~500-428 BC.)
Mixed
The We is the most subtle and purest of things, unmixed, and orders everything.
Pure principle that sets things in motion; without ego of its own.
Source : Fragments, DK 59 B12
Socrate (v. 470-399 of. J.-C.)
Agreement
Take care of your soul more than your body and riches; an unexamined life is not worth living.
Self-examination distinguishes what serves the ego from what serves the soul.
Source : Platon, Apologie de Socrate, 29d-30b ; 38a
Leucippe (Ve p. of. J.-C.)
Disagreement
Nothing happens by chance, everything is done by reason and necessity; atoms and void.
The movement of life explained without ego or soul-receptacle.
Source : Fragment (Aétius), DK 67 B2
Démocrite (v. 460-v. 370 of. J.-C.)
Mixed
The soul is made of highly mobile atoms of fire; serenity comes from the moderation of pleasures.
Mobile soul-fire and measure of desire; refusal of an immaterial soul.
Source : De l'âme, I, 2, 403b-404a
Platon (428-348 by J.-C.)
Agreement
The soul is always in motion and a source of movement; it has three parts (desire, heart, reason); to philosophize is to purify it.
Soul-motive energy, nourishing desires to govern, purification.
Source : Phèdre ; République ; Phédon, Phèdre 245c-246a ; République IV 436a-441c ; Phédon 66b-67d
Aristote (384-322 by J.-C.)
Agreement
The nutritive soul is common to all living beings (to nourish oneself, to reproduce); contemplation is the supreme life.
Nutrition is the foundation of life, even in the hummingbird; man is distinguished by contemplative intellect.
Source : De l'âme ; Éthique à Nicomaque, De l'âme II, 4, 415a23-b7 ; Éthique à Nicomaque X, 7, 1177a12-1178a8
Épicure (341-270 by J.-C.)
Mixed
Classify desires (naturally necessary, naturally unnecessary, vain); the soul is material and dissolves.
Control of appetites; but a mortal soul.
Source : Lettre à Ménécée ; Lettre à Hérodote, Ménécée 127-132 ; Hérodote 63-67
Bhagavad-Gîtâ (Inside, env. IIe p. of. J.-C.)
Agreement
Beings are born from food; the Lord is the digestive fire in the living; the ahaṃkāra makes one believe "it is I who act"; equal vision for all beings.
Food, fire, and ego are linked; the ego is in every creature.
Source : Bhagavad-Gîtâ, III, 14 ; XV, 14 ; III, 27 ; VII, 4 ; V, 18
Patañjali (2nd century BC - 4th century AD, dating uncertain)
Agreement
Yoga is the cessation of mental fluctuations; asmitā, the feeling of self, is an obstacle; inner light calms.
Purify and master the ego through concentration.
Source : Yoga-Sūtra, I, 2 ; II, 3 ; II, 6 ; I, 36
Lucrèce (v. 94-v. 55 of. J.-C.)
Disagreement
Soul and spirit are material and mortal; temperaments vary according to species (lion, deer).
Recognizes a characteristic specific to animals; rejects the eternal soul.
Source : De rerum natura, chant III
Agreement
A sacred spirit dwells within us, observing and guarding our actions.
An inner presence distinct from passions.
Source : Lettres à Lucilius, 41
Agreement
A struggle between flesh and spirit; it is no longer I who live; spirit, soul and body.
The ego that must be detached from in order to allow the spirit to act.
Source : Épître aux Romains ; Galates ; 1 Thessaloniciens, Romains 7, 15-24 ; Galates 2, 20 ; 1 Thess. 5, 23
Évangile de Jean (Ier-IIe s.)
Agreement
Life was the light of men; God is Spirit; he must increase, but I must decrease.
Light (Tejas) and the decline of the ego.
Source : Évangile selon Jean, 1, 4-5 ; 4, 24 ; 3, 30
Agreement
Distinguish what depends on us (judgment, desire) from what does not.
Mastering motivations.
Source : Manuel, 1
Agreement
The being is made of a small body, a small breath and an intelligence; it is always possible to withdraw into oneself.
Breath as energy; inner withdrawal.
Source : Pensées, XII, 3 ; IV, 3
Mixed
The self is neither identical to nor distinct from the aggregates; attachment to the self is emptiness.
Dissolution of the ego; but no soul-receptacle.
Source : Mūlamadhyamakakārikā, XVIII, 1-6
Agreement
Return to yourself and sculpt your own statue; flight from the alone to the One.
Purification and contemplation of the inner light.
Source : Ennéades, I, 6 [1], 9 ; VI, 9 [9], 11
Augustin d'Hippone (354-430)
Mixed
You were inside me and I was outside; food is a remedy that one must be careful not to enjoy; the three concupiscences.
The ego struggling with food; but framed by sin.
Source : Confessions, X, 27, 38 ; X, 30-31
Bhartrihari (~And so on.)
Agreement
The Word (śabda-brahman), without beginning or end, is the principle of manifestation.
Foundation of auditory contemplation, Shabda.
Source : Vākyapadīya, I, 1
Agreement
Superposition (adhyāsa) of the self and the non-self on the Self; discernment dispels illusion.
The ego is confused with the soul: it is this confusion that you are referring to.
Source : Commentaire aux Brahma-Sūtra ; Vivekacūḍāmaṇi, Introduction (adhyāsa-bhāṣya)
Abhinavagupta (v. 950-1016)
Mixed
Consciousness is free and creative energy (śakti); the "I" does not disappear, it becomes perfect (pūrṇāhantā).
Soul and creative energy; the ego transfigured rather than abolished.
Source : Tantrāloka
Agreement
Hierarchy of lights; the soul is light, knowledge is illumination.
Way of the light, near Téjas.
Source : Le Livre de la Sagesse orientale (Ḥikmat al-ishrāq)
Agreement
The heart of the perfect man can receive any form; the soul that incites evil must be purified.
The heart as a receptacle; purification of the ego (nafs).
Source : Fuṣūṣ al-ḥikam
Thomas d'Aquin (1225-1274)
Mixed
Powers of the soul: nutritive, sensitive, intellectual; the soul is the form of the body.
The same gradation as in Aristotle, but the soul is not a receptacle.
Source : Somme théologique, I, q. 78, a. 1 ; I, q. 76
Maître Eckhart (~1260-1328)
Agreement
Poverty of spirit: wanting nothing, knowing nothing, having nothing; the spark of the soul.
Withdrawal of the ego so that the soul may remain.
Source : Sermons, Sermon 52 ; Sermon 2
Michel de Montaigne (1533-1592)
Mixed
It rejects the superiority of man over beasts; animals reason and have passions.
Ego and intelligence in animals; a critique of the human-animal distinction.
Source : Essais, II, 12
Jean de la Croix (1542-1591)
Agreement
Purification of the senses and the mind; to taste everything, seek to taste nothing.
Purification of the ego through detachment.
Source : Montée du Carmel, I, 13
Agreement
Fire and light are the principles of the soul and of nature.
Fire and light as the path of the soul.
Source : Aurore (Aurora)
René Descartes (1596-1650)
Disagreement
Animals are machines without thought; the self is thought.
Deny the animal ego and the hummingbird.
Source : Discours de la méthode ; Lettre à Morus (1649), V
Blaise Pascal (1623-1662)
Mixed
The self is hateful; self-love becomes the center of everything.
Critique of the ego; within a moral and religious framework.
Source : Pensées, Br. 455
Baruch Spinoza (1632-1677)
Agreement
Each thing strives to persevere in its being (conatus); there is sentience in animals.
The vital ego-drive, shared by all living beings.
Source : Éthique, III, 6-9 ; IV, 37, scolie 1
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz (1646-1716)
Agreement
All monads have perception and appetite; man rises through self-awareness and knowledge of necessary truths.
Ego common to all living things, more developed in humans.
Source : Monadologie, § 14-19 ; § 29-30
Disagreement
There is no simple and identical self, only a bundle of perceptions; animals reason.
Challenges the ego-substance; admits animal reason.
Source : Traité de la nature humaine, I, 4, 6 ; I, 3, 16
Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712-1778)
Agreement
Self-love, which is natural and vital, is distinct from self-esteem, which is comparative and social.
Two sides of the ego: self-preservation and pride.
Source : Discours sur l'origine de l'inégalité, première partie ; note XV
Emmanuel Kant (1724-1804)
Agreement
The "I think" accompanies all my representations; having the "I" elevates man above all other living beings.
A more developed ego in men.
Source : Critique de la raison pure ; Anthropologie du point de vue pragmatique, B131-132 ; § 1
Johann Gottlieb Fichte (1762-1814)
Mixed
The Self posits itself.
The ego as an act, but erected into an absolute principle.
Source : Doctrine de la science (1794), § 1
Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel (1770-1831)
Mixed
Self-awareness is desire: it is confirmed by consuming the object.
Link between ego, desire and consumption.
Source : Phénoménologie de l'esprit, chap. IV
Arthur Schopenhauer (1788-1860)
Mixed
The will to live animates every being, even the animal; it denies itself through compassion and asceticism.
Common life force; liberation through negation of the will, with a moral basis.
Source : Le Monde comme volonté et comme représentation, livre IV
Gustav Fechner (1801-1887)
Agreement
Les plantes et toute la nature ont une âme.
Soul diffused throughout all living things.
Source : Nanna, ou l'âme des plantes (1848)
Søren Kierkegaard (1813-1855)
Agreement
The self is a relationship that relates to itself.
The ego as a relationship that opens itself to a foundation.
Source : Traité du désespoir (La Maladie à mort), début de la première partie
Sri Ramakrishna Paramahamsa (1836-1886)
Agreement
The "self" and "mine" are ignorance; the mature ego, the servant's ego, remains after awakening.
The ego is not abolished but purified.
Source : L'Évangile de Sri Ramakrishna
William James (1842-1910)
Agreement
The Self comprises a material, social, and spiritual Self.
Distinction of the layers of the ego.
Source : Principes de psychologie, ch. X
Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900)
Mixed
The body is a great reason; behind the ego stands the Self; beyond good and evil.
The ego rooted in the body; liberation beyond the moral framework.
Source : Ainsi parlait Zarathoustra ; Par-delà bien et mal, I, « Des contempteurs du corps »
Sigmund Freud (1856-1939)
Mixed
The self is not master in its own house; it is formed from drives.
Ego arising from the drive, including hunger.
Source : Le Moi et le Ça (1923), ch. II
Henri Bergson (1859-1941)
Agreement
The vital impulse is a spiritual energy; the soul overflows the body.
Soul as creative energy.
Source : L'Énergie spirituelle (1919) ; L'Évolution créatrice (1907)
Alfred North Whitehead (1861-1947)
Agreement
Current opportunities are drops of experience; all reality tests.
Even the hummingbird possesses subjectivity.
Source : Procès et réalité (1929)
Swami Vivekananda (1863-1902)
Agreement
Prana is the energy that animates everything; yoga masters the mind.
Vital energy and mastery of the ego.
Source : Raja-Yoga (1896)
Georges Gurdjieff (~1866/1877-1949)
Agreement
Three forms of nourishment: food, air, impressions; the false personality.
The journey of food in relation to the ego.
Source : Ouspensky, Fragments d'un enseignement inconnu
Sri Aurobindo (1872-1950)
Agreement
Creative Consciousness-Force (Chit-Tapas); the psychic being behind the ego.
Creative energy and the distinction between soul and ego.
Source : La Vie divine
Agreement
Man is a "spirit" capable of saying no to impulses; the animal is caught up in the vital impulse.
What distinguishes man from animal.
Source : La Situation de l'homme dans le monde (1928)
Carl Gustav Jung (1875-1961)
Mixed
The Ego is the center of consciousness; the Self is the totality of the psyche.
Distinction between ego and soul in the form of Me/Self.
Source : Aïon (1951), ch. I-II
Ramana Maharshi (1879-1950)
Agreement
To seek "Who am I?"; the ego, the thought "I", is the root; at its source the Self is revealed.
Purification of the ego through investigation into its source.
Source : Qui suis-je ?
Pierre Teilhard de Chardin (1881-1955)
Agreement
Everything has an "inside"; energy is tangential and radial; reflection distinguishes man.
Inner energy and reflective ego, unique to man.
Source : Le Phénomène humain, I, 3 ; III, 1
Ludwig Wittgenstein (1889-1951)
Mixed
The subject does not belong to the world; it is a limit of the world.
Where is the ego? Not in the world.
Source : Tractatus, 5.632
Paramahansa Yogananda (1893-1952)
Agreement
Aum, cosmic vibration, and spiritual light; Kriya Yoga.
Sound and light as pathways.
Source : Autobiographie d'un yogi (1946)
Jiddu Krishnamurti (1895-1986)
Mixed
The thinker is thought; observation without method liberates.
Liberation of the ego; but rejection of "methods".
Source : Se libérer du connu (1969)
Jacques Lacan (1901-1981)
Mixed
The self is formed in the image of the mirror, a lack of self-knowledge.
The ego constructs; the text also mentions birds (pigeon).
Source : Écrits, « Le stade du miroir » (1949)
Agreement
Metabolism is the first form of freedom: the organism maintains itself by exchanging matter.
Nutrition as the origin of the living "self".
Source : Le Phénomène de la vie (1966)
Jean-Paul Sartre (1905-1980)
Disagreement
The ego is not in consciousness, but in the world, as an object.
There is no place for the ego in the head.
Source : La Transcendance de l'Ego (1936-1937)
Agreement
Decreation: undoing the self to allow grace to pass through.
Purification of the ego.
Source : La Pesanteur et la grâce (1947)
Jacques Monod (1910-1976)
Disagreement
Mutations occur randomly.
The ego does not cause mutations.
Source : Le Hasard et la Nécessité (1970)
Agreement
The order involved: a source of energy from which the world unfolds.
A receptacle of energy and creativity.
Source : La Plénitude de l'univers (1980)
Daniel Dennett (1942-2024)
Disagreement
No "Cartesian theatre": the self is a narrative centre of gravity.
There is no single place for the ego.
Source : La conscience expliquée (1991), ch. 5
Eckhart Tolle (born in 1948)
Agreement
The ego is identification with thought-forms; the present moment liberates.
Ego to be observed rather than fought.
Source : Le Pouvoir du moment présent (1997)
Christof Koch (born in 1956)
Agreement
Consciousness in mammals and birds; Cambridge Declaration (2012).
Makes a self plausible in the hummingbird.
Source : Déclaration de Cambridge sur la conscience (2012)
Giulio Tononi (born in 1960)
Agreement
Consciousness is integrated information, a matter of degree.
Ego more or less developed depending on the degree.
Source : Théorie de l'information intégrée
Philip Goff (born in 1983)
Agreement
Panpsychism: consciousness is constitutive of matter.
Soul as a background diffused throughout reality.
Source : Galileo's Error (2019)