Philosopher (era)
Position
Statement
Connection
Ptahhotep (Egypt, Fifth Dynasty, around 2400 BC.)
Agreement
Pride and greed distance us from Ma'at; listening and self-control bring order to the being
The slopes that raise or increase the load
Source : Maximes
Rishi (verses 1500-1200 AD.)
Agreement
Beyond being and non-being, the origin remains a mystery that only the inner gaze can touch.
The foundation transcends the physical and the ego
Source : Rig-Véda, X, 129 (Nāsadīya Sūkta)
Uddalaka Aruni (9th-8th centuries BC)
Agreement
The subtle Self is the essence of everything and of being: "that, you are."
The third identity as Self beneath the body and ego
Source : Chāndogya Upaniṣad, VI, 8, 7
Thalès de Milet (624-546 by J.-C.)
Mixed
A single principle (water) and a world "full of gods," according to Aristotle: matter and divinity not separate
A matter already inhabited, which nuances the physical equation = atheism
Source : Aristote, De l'âme, I, 5, 411a7
Mixed
Criticism of gods fashioned in the image of man, but affirmation of a single god without human resemblance
The concept projected as a stereotype that hinders
Source : Fragments, DK 21 B 23
Lao-Tseu (VIe p. of. J.-C.)
Agreement
Knowing oneself is enlightening; returning to the root brings peace.
Self-awareness as liberation
Source : Dao De Jing, 16 ; 33
Bouddha (~Ve p. of. J.-C.)
Mixed
Body and self are impermanent aggregates without a substantial self; lucid vision liberates
They converge on the illusion of the ego, diverge on the existence of a Self.
Source : Saṃyutta Nikāya, 22, 59 (Anattalakkhaṇa Sutta)
Confucius (551-479 by J.-C.)
Mixed
Life is a step-by-step journey of self-discovery; reserve before spirits, priority to humanity
Maturation by degrees, without metaphysics of the soul
Source : Entretiens, II, 4 ; XI, 12
Agreement
Logos is common, but most live in private thought; "I have sought myself."
Transcending the ego through lucidity
Source : Fragments, DK 22 B 2 ; B 101
Agreement
Distinguish the path of truth from the opinion of mortals, a source of error.
Opinion as a stereotype that hinders
Source : Poème, B 1 ; B 8
Socrate (verses 470-399 of. J.-C.)
Agreement
Taking care of one's soul before the body and riches; self-examination makes for a worthwhile life.
Priority of the soul over the physical and the ego
Source : Platon, Apologie de Socrate, 29d-30b ; 38a
Démocrite (v. 460-v. 370 of. J.-C.)
Disagreement
Only atoms and void exist, the rest is convention; the soul is material; ideal of serenity
Physical identity as the only reality
Source : Fragments, DK 68 B 125
Platon (428-348 by J.-C.)
Agreement
Tripartite soul; conversion of the gaze from the cave towards the intelligible
Three instances and liberation through conversion
Source : République, IV, 435b-441c ; VII, 514a-518d
Aristote (384-322 by J.-C.)
Mixed
Three souls (vegetative, sensitive, intellectual): the soul as the form of the body; the active intellect is separable.
Natural tripartition, without soul separate from body
Source : De l'âme, II, 3 ; III, 5
Épicure (341-270 by J.-C.)
Disagreement
Material soul, death is nothing to us; wisdom of measured pleasure
Wisdom of the body without transcendence
Source : Lettre à Ménécée, 124-125
Bhagavad-Gîtâ (Inside, env. IIe p. of. J.-C.)
Agreement
Sense, mind, and intelligence are transcended by the Self; the three guṇas either elevate or hinder
Beneficial or harmful energies, ahaṃkāra as ego
Source : Bhagavad-Gîtâ, III, 42 ; VII, 4 ; XIV, 5-18
Patañjali (2nd century BC - 4th century AD, dating uncertain)
Agreement
Yoga stills mental fluctuations; the ego (asmitā) is among the causes of suffering
Liberation through lucidity about the mind and the ego
Source : Yoga-Sūtra, I, 2 ; II, 3
Lucrèce (v. 94-v. 55 of. J.-C.)
Disagreement
The soul is mortal; the fear of the gods and of death is born of illusion.
Materialism as an "atheism" of the physical
Source : De la nature, III, 830
Agreement
A sacred spirit dwells within us as observer and guardian; mastery of the passions
The inner presence
Source : Lettres à Lucilius, 41, 2
Agreement
Being is body, soul, and spirit; the flesh is opposed to the spirit; new life
Triad and the struggle of energies
Source : 1 Thessaloniciens ; Galates, 1 Th 5, 23 ; Ga 5, 16-25
Agreement
It is our judgments about things that trouble us; liberation through the examination of representations
Stereotypes as judgments that hinder
Source : Manuel, 1 ; 5
Évangile de Jean (Ier-IIe s.)
Agreement
Born from above, of water and the Spirit; that which is born of the flesh is flesh
The third birth
Source : Évangile de Jean, 3, 3-8
Agreement
Man is flesh, breath, and guiding principle; watch over the latter.
almost identical triad
Source : Pensées, II, 2
Gnosticisme et Valentiniens (IIe-IVe s.)
Mixed
Three types of humans (hylic, psychic, pneumatic); liberation through gnosis
Triad, but elitist determinism
Source : Irénée, Contre les hérésies, I, 7, 5
Mixed
Nothing has an independent existence; the self is neither absolutely affirmed nor denied.
Empty the ego, but reject a substantial foundation
Source : Mūlamadhyamakakārikā, XVIII, 6
Agreement
Going inward and sculpting one's own statue; a journey back to the One
The inner return
Source : Ennéades, I, 6 [1], 9
Augustin d'Hippone (354-430)
Agreement
God is more intimate than my own innermost self; returning to oneself
Presence at the heart of inner life
Source : Confessions, III, 6, 11 ; X, 27, 38
Agreement
The Self is conflated with the body and the mind; three bodies, five sheaths
Physical and egoic identities as superpositions
Source : Commentaire des Brahma-Sūtra, Introduction (adhyāsa)
Agreement
Man is a mirror of the divine; knowing oneself leads to knowing one's Lord
Experience as knowledge of oneself and of the divine
Source : Fusūs al-ḥikam
Thomas d'Aquin (1225-1274)
Mixed
Vegetative, sensitive, and intellectual soul; form of the body; end in the vision of God
Ternary, but a substantial union of soul and body
Source : Somme théologique, I, q. 76, a. 1
Maître Eckhart (~1260-1328)
Agreement
Birth of the Word in the soul; detachment from self
The inner birth
Source : Sermons
Michel de Montaigne (1533-1592)
Mixed
To enjoy one's being loyally is a perfection; the humility of reason
Values lived experience without asserting transcendence.
Source : Essais, III, 13
Jean de la Croix (1542-1591)
Agreement
Purification of the senses and then of the mind through the nights
Stripping away of the body and the ego
Source : La Montée du Carmel ; La Nuit obscure
Agreement
Man's triple life; inner struggle between anger and light
Ternary and opposing energies
Source : De la triple vie de l'homme
René Descartes (1596-1650)
Mixed
The self is a thinking substance distinct from the body; God guarantees knowledge
It makes ego the starting point, which the text aims to transcend.
Source : Méditations métaphysiques, II ; VI
Blaise Pascal (1623-1662)
Agreement
Three orders: body, spirit, charity; the self is hateful
Ternary and critique of the ego
Source : Pensées, Brunschvicg 793 (Lafuma 308) ; Br. 455 (L. 597)
Baruch Spinoza (1632-1677)
Agreement
Three kinds of knowledge; bondage to the passions; intellectual love of God
Liberation through understanding
Source : Éthique, II, 40, scolie 2 ; V, 25-33
Disagreement
The self is merely a collection of perceptions.
Reduces identity to its states, without foundation
Source : Traité de la nature humaine, I, IV, 6
Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712-1778)
Mixed
Distinguish between self-love (natural) and self-esteem (social, born of comparison)
Two faces of the ego, one that elevates, the other that weighs you down.
Source : Discours sur l'origine de l'inégalité, Note XV
Emmanuel Kant (1724-1804)
Mixed
The self is not knowable as a substance; limits of reason; respect for the moral law
Ego deconstructed, moral dimension preserved
Source : Critique de la raison pure, Paralogismes
Arthur Schopenhauer (1788-1860)
Mixed
Individuation is a veil of Maya; selfishness is the effect of the will; compassion liberates
Illusory ego and liberation through self-transcendence
Source : Le Monde comme volonté et comme représentation, IV, § 63-68
Auguste Comte (1798-1857)
Disagreement
Law of the three stages: theological, metaphysical, positive
An inverted ternary, which transcends the divine
Source : Cours de philosophie positive, 1re leçon
Ludwig Feuerbach (1804-1872)
Disagreement
God is the projection of human essence
The human ego as the sole reality of the divine
Source : L'Essence du christianisme
Søren Kierkegaard (1813-1855)
Agreement
Three stages (aesthetic, ethical, religious); the self is a relationship that relates to itself
Stages and self-discovery in faith
Source : La Maladie à mort, I, A, a
Sri Ramakrishna Paramahamsa (1836-1886)
Agreement
The "self" is a veil of māyā; it dissolves in the love and experience of the divine
Dissolution of the ego through experience
Source : L'Évangile de Sri Ramakrishna
William James (1842-1910)
Agreement
My material, social, and spiritual self; conversion as a second birth
Three almost identical identities
Source : Principes de psychologie, ch. X
Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900)
Mixed
The body is the great reason; three metamorphoses of the spirit; the death of God
Values the body and becoming, diverges on God
Source : Ainsi parlait Zarathoustra, I, « Des contempteurs du corps » ; « Des trois métamorphoses »
Sigmund Freud (1856-1939)
Disagreement
Id, me, superego; religion is an illusion
Three instances without a spiritual dimension
Source : Le Moi et le Ça ; L'Avenir d'une illusion
Edmund Husserl (1859-1938)
Mixed
Returning to lived experience (Erlebnis) by setting aside received ideas
Personal experience as a source, without religious intent
Source : Idées directrices pour une phénoménologie
Henri Bergson (1859-1941)
Agreement
My superficial, social self versus my deep, lived-in self.
Two levels of identity and access through lived experience
Source : Essai sur les données immédiates de la conscience, ch. III
Swami Vivekananda (1863-1902)
Agreement
The Self is beyond the body and the ego; every soul is divine
Transcending the first two identities
Source : Raja-Yoga ; Jnana-Yoga
Georges Gurdjieff (~1866/1877-1949)
Agreement
Man is a being with three centers (motor, emotional, intellectual), asleep like a machine
Three foundations and awakening
Source : Récits de Belzébuth à son petit-fils
Sri Aurobindo (1872-1950)
Agreement
Being physical, vital, mental and soul (psychic being); evolution of consciousness
Evolution and layering of being
Source : La Vie divine
Bertrand Russell (1872-1970)
Disagreement
No proof of God; a scientific worldview
Theoretical atheism, which the text links to the physical
Source : Pourquoi je ne suis pas chrétien
Agreement
Vital, psychic, and spiritual (Geist) layers; man is capable of saying no to his impulses.
Layering and spirit as the final level
Source : La Situation de l'homme dans le cosmos
Carl Gustav Jung (1875-1961)
Agreement
The ego is not the center; individuation leads to the Self.
Transcending the ego towards the Self
Source : Aïon
Agreement
The I-He relationship objectifies; the I-Thou relationship renders being whole
Relational experience as birth
Source : Je et Tu
Ramana Maharshi (1879-1950)
Agreement
Seeking to understand the origin of the thought "I" dissolves the ego
Investigation, the path of lived experience
Source : Qui suis-je ?
Pierre Teilhard de Chardin (1881-1955)
Agreement
Evolution from the geosphere to the biosphere and then to the noosphere; ascension of consciousness
Evolutionary process
Source : Le Phénomène humain
Gaston Bachelard (1884-1962)
Agreement
Preconceived ideas constitute epistemological obstacles that must be overcome.
The stereotypes that hinder
Source : La Formation de l'esprit scientifique, ch. I
Martin Heidegger (1889-1976)
Mixed
The impersonal "one" dilutes existence into the impersonal; a call for authenticity
Social stereotypes without explicit transcendence
Source : Être et temps, § 27
Ludwig Wittgenstein (1889-1951)
Mixed
The subject is not in the world but is its limit; the unspeakable reveals itself
Silence in the face of what is happening
Source : Tractatus logico-philosophicus, 5.632 ; 6.54 ; 7
Paramahansa Yogananda (1893-1952)
Agreement
Three bodies (physical, astral, causal) and one Self
Indian tradition of the three bodies
Source : Autobiographie d'un yogi
Jiddu Krishnamurti (1895-1986)
Agreement
Freeing oneself from conditioning through observation without the known
Breaking free from stereotypes
Source : La Première et Dernière Liberté
Jacques Lacan (1901-1981)
Mixed
The self is formed in the image of the mirror, with unknowing
Ego as an imaginary construct, without spiritual escape
Source : Écrits, « Le stade du miroir »
Jean-Paul Sartre (1905-1980)
Disagreement
Existence precedes essence; bad faith; no God
Freedom without divine foundation
Source : L'Être et le Néant
Mircea Eliade (1907-1986)
Agreement
Initiation is a mystical birth, through ritual death and rebirth.
Third birth
Source : Naissances mystiques
Maurice Merleau-Ponty (1908-1961)
Mixed
The body itself is the subject of lived experience
The body as the site of lived experience
Source : Phénoménologie de la perception
Abraham Maslow (1908-1970)
Agreement
Hierarchy of needs; self-transcendence and culminating experiences
Step by step towards self-transcendence
Source : Vers une psychologie de l'être
Agreement
Gravity versus grace; decreation of the self
Slopes that increase in weight or height
Source : La Pesanteur et la Grâce
Jacques Monod (1910-1976)
Disagreement
Chance and necessity; rejection of the animist alliance
Scientific materialism
Source : Le Hasard et la Nécessité
Disagreement
The absurd without transcendence; lucidity and revolt
Lucidity without the divine
Source : Le Mythe de Sisyphe
Agreement
Thought fragments; reality is an encompassing whole
Go beyond the fragment
Source : La Plénitude de l'univers
Agreement
Experience is the self-affection of Life, prior to the world
Experienced as a foundation
Source : C'est moi la vérité
Agreement
Ancient philosophy is a spiritual exercise in self-transformation.
Liberation through practice
Source : Exercices spirituels et philosophie antique
Mixed
Personal identity is not what matters
It aligns with Buddhism on the ego
Source : Reasons and Persons, Partie III
Daniel Dennett (1942-2024)
Disagreement
The self is a narrative center of gravity, constructed
Ego as a useful fiction
Source : La Conscience expliquée
Eckhart Tolle (born in 1948)
Agreement
Identification with form is the ego; presence liberates
Transcending the ego through presence
Source : Nouvelle Terre
André Comte-Sponville (born in 1952)
Mixed
Atheism and spirituality without God; the mind as an experience of immanence
This contradicts the equation atheism = low slope
Source : L'Esprit de l'athéisme