Philosopher (era)
Position
Statement
Connection
Ptahhotep (Egypt, Fifth Dynasty, around 2400 BC.)
Agreement
Listening is the first of virtues; the wise person learns by listening and follows Ma'at.
Listening as the gateway to wisdom, before any practice: Shabda
Source : Maximes (Papyrus Prisse), Épilogue sur l'écoute
Agreement
The Word (Vāc) is queen of the universe; the splendor of Savitṛ inspires thought
Word and light already united at the cradle of the Veda
Source : Rig-Véda, X, 125 ; III, 62, 10
Uddalaka Aruni (9th–8th centuries BC)
Agreement
Fire (tejas), water, and food are the primary forms; the Self is "that which you are".
Tejas as the first principle; the Self distinct from the envelope
Source : Chāndogya Upaniṣad, VI, 4 ; VI, 8, 7
Thalès de Milet (624–546 AD.)
Mixed
The world is full of souls (according to Aristotle); the "know thyself" is attributed to it.
Soul present everywhere, without ego theory
Source : Aristote, De l'âme, I, 5, 411a7
Anaximandre de Milet (c. 610–c. 546 AD.)
Mixed
The separated beings pay for their injustice by returning to the limitless.
Individuation as separation, an echo of the ego isolating itself
Source : Fragment (Simplicius), DK 12 B1
Agreement
Music, numbers, and disciplined living purify the soul.
Sound as a method of purification: Shabda
Source : Tradition (Porphyre, Vie de Pythagore)
Mixed
The divine sees, thinks, and hears in its entirety; a critique of anthropomorphism
Seeing and hearing are elevated to the divine; the human ego projects its images
Source : Fragments, DK 21 B24
Lao-Tseu (VIe p. of. J.-C.)
Mixed
The greatest sound is almost silence, the greatest image formless; to know oneself is clarity
Shabda and Tejas have passed into silence and inner clarity
Source : Tao Te King, XLI ; XXXIII
Bouddha (~Ve p. of. J.-C.)
Mixed
The self is composite and without substance (anattā); the self is mastered by the Eightfold Path
The method has been proven; the ego is dissolved rather than restored.
Source : Dhammapada ; Anattalakkhana Sutta, Dhammapada 160 ; SN 22, 59
Agreement
Study and reflection go together; overcoming oneself to return to humanity (ren); music shapes the being
Reading and methodology as self-education; music as awakening
Source : Entretiens, II, 15 ; XII, 1 ; VII, 14
Mixed
The limits of the soul are unsearchable, its logos is profound; eyes and ears are poor witnesses without intelligence.
Listening and seeing are not enough; one must have logos.
Source : Fragments, DK 22 B45 ; B107
Mixed
The poem leads towards the light and separates truth from opinion; one sees through the mind
Light as an initiatory journey; the senses alone deceive
Source : Poème, B1 ; B4
Socrate (verses 470–399 AD.)
Agreement
An unexamined life is not worth living; an inner voice (daimonion) holds him back.
Self-examination as a method; inner voice comparable to Shabda
Source : Platon, Apologie de Socrate, 38a ; 31c–d
Leucippe (Ve p. of. J.-C.)
Disagreement
Everything is atoms and emptiness, including the soul; nothing happens without reason and necessity.
No soul distinct from matter: divergence from the soul-ego-body triad
Source : Fragments, DK 67 B2
Démocrite (v. 460–v. 370 AD.)
Mixed
The soul is made of atoms; tranquility (euthymia) is achieved through moderation; the senses and the intellect are opposed.
A method of appeasement, yes; a separated soul, no.
Source : Fragments, DK 68 B125 ; B191
Agreement
The soul, entangled in the body, turns towards truth through education; sight and hearing are given for philosophy
The most direct connection: soul, body, education, sight and listening
Source : République ; Phédon ; Timée, VII, 518b–d ; Phédon 79c–d ; Timée 47a–e
Mixed
All men desire knowledge, a sign of which is the love of sensations, especially sight; contemplation is the supreme good; the soul is the form of the body
Capacity to know and contemplate confirmed; "enveloped" soul disputed
Source : Métaphysique ; Éthique à Nicomaque, A, 1, 980a21 ; X, 7, 1177a
Agreement
The "fasting of the heart": listening not with the ear or the mind, but with the breath; self-forgetfulness
Inner listening of the Shabda type; ego lightened by self-forgetfulness
Source : Zhuangzi, chap. 4 ; chap. 6
Mixed
The fear of the gods and of death troubles the soul; the knowledge of nature dispels it.
Fear is an obstacle, overcome by study; but the soul is material.
Source : Maximes capitales ; Lettre à Ménécée, Max. XI–XII ; Lettre 124–125
Bhagavad-Gîtâ (Inside, env. IIe p. by. J.-C.)
Agreement
One must rise through one's own efforts; the ego (ahaṅkāra) makes one believe "I am the agent"; splendor (tejas) is divine
Ego, method and light in the same text
Source : Bhagavad-Gîtâ, VI, 5 ; III, 27 ; VII, 4 ; XV, 12
Patañjali (2nd century BC–4th century AD, dating uncertain)
Agreement
Afflictions: ignorance, egoism (asmitā), attraction, aversion, fear of death; Om is the word of the Absolute; a luminous state without pain
Fear, ignorance, and ego are listed as obstacles; Shabda and Tejas as supports
Source : Yoga-sûtra, II, 3 ; I, 27 ; I, 36
Lucrèce (v. 94–v. 55 of. J.-C.)
Mixed
Neither the sun's rays nor the daylight can dispel the terror of the soul, but the study of nature
Fear overcome by the light of knowledge, not by the sun
Source : De la nature des choses, I, 146–148
Agreement
Read little and well; the body is a burden to the soul; learn from the masters
Reading, lectures, and a soul weighed down by the body
Source : Lettres à Lucilius, 2 ; 65, 16 ; 108
Agreement
Man is spirit, soul, and body; inner struggle; faith comes from listening
Triad close to the text; listening is the foundation of faith
Source : Épîtres, 1 Th 5, 23 ; Rm 7, 15–24 ; Rm 10, 17
Évangile de Jean (Ier–IIe s.)
Agreement
In the beginning was the Word (Logos), the life and light of humankind.
Word and light united: Shabda and Tejas in the Christian tradition
Source : Évangile selon Jean, 1, 1–9 ; 8, 12
Agreement
It is not things but judgments that are troubling; the discipline of desire and assent
Method (askèsis) for lightening the ego
Source : Manuel, 1 ; 5
Gnosticisme (Ier–IIIe s.)
Mixed
"There is light within the man of light"; the divine spark, captive to ignorance, is liberated by gnosis.
Inner light and ignorance; but the body is devalued there.
Source : Évangile selon Thomas, logion 24
Agreement
To withdraw into oneself; the free soul is a citadel; to serve the inner genius
The contemplative residence in itself
Source : Pensées, IV, 3 ; VIII, 48 ; II, 13
Valentiniens (IIe–IVe s.)
Mixed
Ignorance breeds anguish and terror; knowledge liberates
Ignorance and fear as a source of spiritual failure
Source : Évangile de Vérité (Nag Hammadi)
Disagreement
The self has no inherent nature; afflictions cease with the end of mental constructs.
The ego is not to be restored but to be seen as empty
Source : Stances du Milieu (Mūlamadhyamakakārikā), XVIII, 5–6
Umasvati (jaïnisme, IIe–Ve s.)
Agreement
The soul (jīva), bound by karmic matter, is liberated through right vision, right knowledge, and right conduct.
A wrapped soul and a three-step method
Source : Tattvārtha-sūtra, I, 1
Agreement
Go within yourself and sculpt your statue; contemplation purifies the soul.
Purification of the soul through contemplation
Source : Ennéades, I, 6 [1], 9 ; III, 8 [30]
Augustin d'Hippone (354–430)
Agreement
You screamed and shattered my deafness; you shone and banished my blindness.
Hearing and sight as two gateways to the divine: Shabda and Tejas
Source : Confessions, X, 27, 38
Agreement
The mind clings to a "self" (self-perception, confusion, pride, self-love); the deep consciousness is transformed
A precise analysis of the ego and its transformation
Source : Trente strophes (Vasubandhu), v. 5–7
Bhartrihari (~And so on.)
Agreement
The Word is the imperishable Brahman, the principle of the world
Shabda-brahman: foundation of Shabda
Source : Vākyapadīya, I, 1
Denys l'Aréopagite (Ve–VIe s.)
Mixed
Contemplation leads to the ray of darkness, beyond the senses and the intellect.
The light surpasses ordinary sight
Source : Théologie mystique, I, 1
Mixed
The ego is a superimposition (adhyāsa); listen, reflect, meditate; the Self is not to be purified
The method has been validated; the ego recognizes itself as illusory rather than recovering.
Source : Commentaire des Brahma-sûtra (introduction)
Agreement
Consciousness is light (prakāśa) and reflective resonance (Supreme Word)
Tejas and Shabda united in Kashmiri Shaivism
Source : Tantrāloka
Mixed
The soul is distinct from the body and the ego, but never separate from the divine; devotion and knowledge
The real soul enveloped, without dissolution of the person
Source : Śrī-bhāṣya
Agreement
The heart is a mirror to be polished; discipline and purification of the soul (nafs)
Purification of the ego through discipline (Sufism)
Source : Revivification des sciences de la religion (Iḥyā'), livres 21–22
Richard de Saint-Victor (†1173)
Agreement
Degrees of contemplation for those who prepare themselves through study and order
A graduated method of contemplation
Source : Benjamin major
Mixed
Philosophy is a duty; the intellect is unique and shared.
Study required, but no individual soul
Source : Discours décisif ; Grand commentaire du De anima
Agreement
The knowledge of God is human perfection; ignorance is the great obstacle
Knowledge and contemplation in Judaism
Source : Guide des égarés, III, 51
Agreement
The world is light of degrees; wisdom is received through illumination.
Tejas as a principle
Source : Hikmat al-ishrāq
Agreement
The heart is a mirror of the divine; the ego is a veil
Soul, ego, and mirror/veil
Source : Les Illuminations de La Mecque
Agreement
To study the Way is to study oneself, and to forget oneself; sounds of the valley, shapes of the mountain
Listening and seeing in Zen practice
Source : Shōbōgenzō, Genjōkōan ; Keisei-sanshoku
Agreement
Listen to the reed: the song of the ney speaks of separation; listening brings us closer
Shabda in Sufism
Source : Mathnawî, I, 1–18
Thomas d'Aquin (1225–1274)
Mixed
The soul is the form of the body; the contemplative life is the highest
Contemplation, yes; a nuanced, "enveloped" soul
Source : Somme théologique, I, q. 76 ; II-II, q. 180
Maître Eckhart (~1260–1328)
Agreement
Detachment; the spark of the soul beyond the ego; poverty of will, knowledge, and possessions
Soul beyond the ego
Source : Sermons, Sermon 52
Grégoire Palamas (1296–1359)
Agreement
Prayer of the heart and uncreated light of Tabor
Shabda (prayer) and Tejas (light) among the Orthodox
Source : Triades pour la défense des saints hésychastes
Nicolas de Cues (1401–1464)
Agreement
Learned ignorance; the icon whose gaze follows the one who gazes upon it
Ignorance and visual contemplation
Source : De la docte ignorance ; De la vision de Dieu
Agreement
The Word (Shabad) guides; whoever understands the Hukam no longer speaks in selfishness (haumai).
Haumai (ego) and Shabad in Sikhism
Source : Japji Sahib, pauri 2
Ignace de Loyola (1491–1556)
Agreement
Spiritual exercises: a method for examining, meditating, and contemplating
The method against inner disorder
Source : Exercices spirituels, [1] ; [23] ; [47]
Thérèse d’Avila (1515–1582)
Agreement
The soul is an inner castle with mansions; prayer is its gate
Very close to the concept of a "contemplative residence"
Source : Le Château intérieur, Premières demeures, ch. 1
Michel de Montaigne (1533–1592)
Mixed
Keeping a back room for oneself; doubt about human vanity
Inward withdrawal, but skepticism towards the methods
Source : Essais, I, 39 ; II, 12
Agreement
Divine sparks captive in bark; repair (tikkun)
Repair close to "restoration"
Source : Tradition lourianique (Haïm Vital)
Jean de la Croix (1542–1591)
Agreement
Purification of the senses and the mind; silent music, sonorous solitude
A deafening silence; but purification comes through the night.
Source : Cantique spirituel ; Montée du Carmel ; Nuit obscure, Cantique spirituel, str. 14–15
Giordano Bruno (1548–1600)
Agreement
The soul rises towards the divine light through heroic fury
Contemplative impulse
Source : Des fureurs héroïques
Agreement
A spark of the soul between light and anger; the inner dawn
Interior light
Source : Aurora
René Descartes (1596–1650)
Mixed
Method is necessary to seek the truth; the soul is distinct from the body
Method and dualism; the ego-cogito in divergence
Source : Règles pour la direction de l'esprit ; Méditations, Règle IV ; Méditation II
Blaise Pascal (1623–1662)
Agreement
All unhappiness stems from not knowing how to remain at rest in a room; the self is hateful.
The bedroom as a contemplative residence; hateful ego
Source : Pensées, L. 136 ; L. 597
Baruch Spinoza (1632–1677)
Mixed
Hope and fear are not good in themselves; knowledge liberates
Fear overcome by knowledge; soul not separated
Source : Éthique, IV, 47 ; V, 23 scolie
Disagreement
The self is merely a collection of perceptions.
Ego sans substance
Source : Traité de la nature humaine, I, 4, 6
Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712–1778)
Agreement
Self-love versus self-esteem; contemplative reverie
Ego social et contemplation solitaire
Source : Discours sur l'inégalité ; Rêveries du promeneur solitaire, note XV ; Cinquième promenade
Emmanuel Kant (1724–1804)
Mixed
Dare to know; the soul is not knowable as substance
Knowledge encouraged, substantial soul unknowable
Source : Qu'est-ce que les Lumières ? ; Critique de la raison pure, Paralogismes (A341/B399)
Johann Gottlieb Fichte (1762–1814)
Mixed
The absolute Self; faith as the path to the destination
The self as task
Source : La Destination de l'homme, livre III
Agreement
"The mysterious path leads inward."
Inner lane
Source : Grains de pollen, fr. 16
Arthur Schopenhauer (1788–1860)
Mixed
Aesthetic contemplation suspends the will; music expresses the Will itself.
Auditory and visual contemplation; but the ego is the will to live.
Source : Le monde comme volonté et comme représentation, § 34 ; § 52
Auguste Comte (1798–1857)
Disagreement
The three-stage law relegates spirituality to an outdated age
Challenge to the spiritual framework
Source : Cours de philosophie positive, 1re leçon
Ludwig Feuerbach (1804–1872)
Disagreement
God is the projection of human essence
The soul and the divine as projections
Source : L'Essence du christianisme
Søren Kierkegaard (1813–1855)
Mixed
Man is spirit, a synthesis of soul and body; the self, despair, and anguish
Triad of soul, body, and mind; anguish and fear
Source : La Maladie à la mort ; Le Concept d'angoisse, La Maladie à la mort, I, A
Agreement
The heart is the divine dwelling place to be purified
Interior residence
Source : Les Paroles cachées
Sri Ramakrishna Paramahamsa (1836–1886)
Agreement
Maintaining a "mature ego" as a servant of God; the ordinary ego veils
An evolving ego rather than an abolished one
Source : L'Évangile de Râmakrishna
William James (1842–1910)
Agreement
My material, social, and spiritual self; mystical states
Multiplicity of the self and contemplative experience
Source : Principes de psychologie ; Les Formes multiples de l'expérience religieuse, ch. X ; leçons XVI–XVII
Friedrich Nietzsche (1844–1900)
Disagreement
"I am entirely body"; the soul is but a word for a part of the body.
Rejection of the triad
Source : Ainsi parlait Zarathoustra, I, Des contempteurs du corps
Sigmund Freud (1856–1939)
Mixed
The self is not master in its own house; oceanic feeling
The discreet ego, the mystic to be interpreted
Source : Une difficulté de la psychanalyse ; Malaise dans la civilisation, Malaise, ch. I
Henri Bergson (1859–1941)
Agreement
Deep self versus superficial self; intuition
The social ego masks a deeper self
Source : Essai sur les données immédiates de la conscience, ch. III
Alfred North Whitehead (1861–1947)
Agreement
Religion is what the individual makes of their solitude
Solitude contemplative
Source : Religion in the Making
Swami Vivekananda (1863–1902)
Agreement
Raja Yoga method: concentration, Om as a symbol
Method, sound and thought
Source : Raja-Yoga
Georges Gurdjieff (~1866/1877–1949)
Agreement
Man sleeps; working on oneself awakens him.
Ego awakened by the method
Source : Récits de Belzébuth à son petit-fils
Mixed
The numinous is both terrifying and fascinating
Fear as a component, not as a mere obstacle
Source : Le Sacré, ch. IV
Sri Aurobindo (1872–1950)
Agreement
The psychic being is distinct from the surface ego
The true soul behind the ego
Source : La Synthèse des Yogas ; La Vie divine
Bertrand Russell (1872–1970)
Disagreement
Religion is born first and foremost from fear
Inversion: Fear as the origin of the spiritual
Source : Pourquoi je ne suis pas chrétien
Carl Gustav Jung (1875–1961)
Agreement
The Self transcends the ego; individuation
Ego relativized by the Self
Source : Aion, ch. IV
Ramana Maharshi (1879–1950)
Mixed
The ego dissolves in the search for the origin of the "I".
Method of investigation; dissolution rather than purification
Source : Qui suis-je ?
Gaston Bachelard (1884–1962)
Agreement
The flame of a candle invites contemplative reverie.
Tejas and visual contemplation
Source : La Flamme d'une chandelle
Ludwig Wittgenstein (1889–1951)
Mixed
The subject does not belong to the world; the inexpressible reveals itself
Ego without entity, silent mystic
Source : Tractatus logico-philosophicus, 5.631–5.641 ; 6.522
Martin Heidegger (1889–1976)
Mixed
Meditative thinking is opposed to calculating thinking.
Contemplation versus calculation
Source : Sérénité, Discours de 1955
Paramahansa Yogananda (1893–1952)
Agreement
The cosmic sound Aum and the spiritual eye of light
Shabda and Tejas in Kriya Yoga
Source : Autobiographie d'un yogi, ch. 26
Jiddu Krishnamurti (1895–1986)
Disagreement
Truth is a pathless land; no method sets you free
Rejection of the method
Source : Dissolution de l'Ordre de l'Étoile (1929)
Disagreement
The "ghost in the machine" is a category error
Rejection of the enveloped soul
Source : La Notion d'esprit, ch. 1
Jacques Lacan (1901–1981)
Mixed
The self is formed in a deceptive image; misrecognition
Ego as a construct and illusion
Source : Écrits, Le stade du miroir
Jean-Paul Sartre (1905–1980)
Disagreement
The ego is not in consciousness but an object of the world
External ego
Source : La Transcendance de l'Ego
Emmanuel Levinas (1906–1995)
Mixed
The ego is the enjoyment of the Same; it opens itself through the face of the other.
Problematic ego, the path through the other
Source : Totalité et Infini
Abraham Joshua Heschel (1907–1972)
Agreement
The Sabbath is a sanctuary in time; radical wonder
Contemplative residence in time
Source : Le Sabbat
Abraham Maslow (1908–1970)
Agreement
Peak experiences; beyond self-fulfillment
Evolving ego
Source : Vers une psychologie de l'être
Agreement
The study develops attention, which is prayer
Study as a method towards contemplation
Source : Attente de Dieu, Réflexions sur le bon usage des études scolaires
Agreement
Thought fragments; attention dissolves identification
Ego-thinking and attention
Source : La Plénitude du monde et l'ordre
Mixed
Life is experienced in the invisible, not in the visible.
Visual limit (Tejas)
Source : C'est moi la vérité
Agreement
Ancient philosophy is a spiritual exercise
The method as a way of life
Source : Exercices spirituels et philosophie antique
Michel Foucault (1926–1984)
Agreement
Spirituality transforms the individual to access the truth
Self-practices
Source : L'Herméneutique du sujet, Cours du 6 janvier 1982, première heure
Daniel Dennett (1942–2024)
Disagreement
The self is a narrative center of gravity.
Ego without a core
Source : La Conscience expliquée, ch. 13
Disagreement
Personal identity is not what matters
Ego lightened by the reductionist view
Source : Reasons and Persons
Eckhart Tolle (born in 1948)
Agreement
Presence in the moment and dissolution of identification with the ego
Observed ego, silent listening
Source : Le Pouvoir du moment présent
André Comte-Sponville (born in 1952)
Mixed
A spirituality without God: communion, fidelity, love
Contemplation without separate soul
Source : L'Esprit de l'athéisme
Byung-Chul Han (born in 1959)
Agreement
To give inaction and contemplation their rightful place
Contemplation versus agitation
Source : Vita contemplativa